As a conscientious pet owner and consumer, you may have found yourself wondering about the origins of those adorable puppies, kittens, and other animals available for purchase at your local PetSmart store. While it‘s easy to be swayed by their cute faces and playful antics, it‘s important to consider the broader implications of where these animals come from and how they ended up in the pet retail system.
In this comprehensive guide, we‘ll take a deep dive into PetSmart‘s animal sourcing practices, examining everything from their official policies and partnerships to the controversies and criticisms surrounding their suppliers. We‘ll also explore the wider pet trade industry and its impact on animal welfare, as well as what you can do as a consumer to make more informed and ethical choices when it comes to pet adoption and ownership.
PetSmart‘s Animal Sourcing: Official Policies and Partnerships
According to PetSmart‘s official statements, the company is committed to sourcing animals from humane and responsible breeders and distributors who meet strict standards for animal care and welfare. On their website, PetSmart claims that they "work with a limited number of USDA licensed and USDA inspected professional pet breeders, as well as a select group of trusted reptile and fish distributors" and that they "do not source pets from puppy or kitten mills."
PetSmart also emphasizes their partnerships with animal rescue organizations through their PetSmart Charities program, which provides space and resources for local shelters to showcase adoptable cats and dogs in their stores. According to PetSmart, this program has facilitated the adoption of over 9 million pets since its inception in 1994.
However, despite these official policies and partnerships, PetSmart‘s animal sourcing practices have been the subject of controversy and criticism from animal welfare advocates. Let‘s take a closer look at some of the specific concerns that have been raised.
Controversies and Criticisms: What Animal Welfare Advocates Say
Animal welfare organizations like PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) have long been critical of PetSmart‘s animal sourcing practices, alleging that the company‘s claims about humane and responsible sourcing do not always match up with reality.
In a 2018 investigative report, PETA accused PetSmart of sourcing animals from large-scale commercial breeding facilities that prioritized profit over animal welfare. Specifically, the report focused on an iguana breeding facility in El Salvador that supplied animals to PetSmart, claiming that the facility kept animals in cramped and unsanitary conditions without proper veterinary care.
PetSmart denied these allegations, stating that they have strict standards for their animal suppliers and regularly inspect their facilities to ensure compliance. However, this is not the first time that PetSmart‘s suppliers have been called into question.
In a 2016 report, the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) found that several of PetSmart‘s small animal suppliers were actually large-scale breeding mills with a history of animal welfare violations. The report identified three specific suppliers – Sun Pet, Reptiles by Mack, and Rainbow World Exotics – that had been cited by the USDA for issues like overcrowding, poor sanitation, and lack of veterinary care.
PetSmart responded to the HSUS report by reiterating their commitment to animal welfare and stating that they would investigate the claims and take appropriate action if necessary. However, the company has not always been transparent about the specific actions they have taken or the results of their investigations.
A Closer Look at PetSmart‘s Animal Suppliers
To better understand the concerns raised by animal welfare advocates, let‘s take a closer look at some of PetSmart‘s major animal suppliers and the species they provide:
Small Animals (Hamsters, Guinea Pigs, Rabbits, etc.)
The majority of PetSmart‘s small animals come from large-scale commercial breeding facilities, sometimes referred to as "animal mills." These facilities prioritize high-volume breeding over individual animal welfare, and have been criticized for keeping animals in cramped, unsanitary conditions with minimal socialization or veterinary care.
Some of PetSmart‘s major small animal suppliers include:
- Sun Pet Ltd. (Atlanta, GA): One of the largest small animal suppliers in the US, Sun Pet has been cited by the USDA for issues like overcrowding, poor sanitation, and lack of veterinary care.
- Ware Manufacturing (Phoenix, AZ): Another large-scale supplier of small animals to pet stores, Ware Manufacturing has faced criticism for their breeding practices and animal care standards.
Reptiles and Amphibians
PetSmart sources their reptiles and amphibians from a variety of different distributors and breeders, both domestic and international. One of their major suppliers is Reptiles by Mack, a large-scale reptile breeding facility based in Ohio.
While Reptiles by Mack claims to prioritize animal welfare and has been recognized by the Pet Industry Joint Advisory Council (PIJAC) for their humane practices, they have also been the subject of controversy. In 2015, the company was investigated by the USDA for allegedly shipping sick and injured animals to pet stores, including PetSmart.
Other major reptile and amphibian suppliers for PetSmart include:
- Segrest Farms (Gibsonton, FL): One of the largest wholesalers of ornamental fish and reptiles in the US, Segrest Farms has faced criticism for their animal care practices and high mortality rates.
- Turtle Source (Fort Myers, FL): A major supplier of aquatic turtles and tortoises, Turtle Source has been accused of sourcing animals from the wild and contributing to the depletion of native populations.
Fish
PetSmart sources their fish from a number of different suppliers, including Fish Mart Inc., a major distributor of ornamental fish based in Florida. Fish Mart has been in business for over 30 years and supplies fish to many of the largest pet retailers in the United States.
While Fish Mart claims to prioritize fish health and welfare, the ornamental fish trade as a whole has been criticized for its environmental impact and the high mortality rates associated with shipping and storing fish in crowded tanks. A 2019 investigation by National Geographic found that up to 70% of aquarium fish die before even reaching pet stores, due to the stresses of transport and poor handling practices.
Other major fish suppliers for PetSmart include:
- Segrest Farms (Gibsonton, FL): In addition to reptiles and amphibians, Segrest Farms is also a major supplier of ornamental fish to pet stores like PetSmart.
- 5D Tropical (Plant City, FL): Another large-scale distributor of ornamental fish, 5D Tropical has been in business for over 25 years and supplies fish to major retailers across the US.
The Bigger Picture: Pet Trade Industry and Animal Welfare
The concerns raised about PetSmart‘s animal sourcing practices are not unique to this one retailer, but rather reflect broader issues within the pet trade industry as a whole.
According to the American Pet Products Association (APPA), over 84 million households in the US own at least one pet, and the pet industry is projected to reach nearly $100 billion in sales by 2023. With such high demand for pets, it‘s no surprise that large-scale commercial breeding facilities have become a major source of animals for pet stores and online retailers.
However, the conditions in these facilities are often far from ideal for animal welfare. A 2010 report by the ASPCA (American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals) found that over 4,000 "puppy mills" were operating in the US, producing over 2 million puppies per year. These facilities are characterized by overcrowding, unsanitary conditions, lack of socialization, and inadequate veterinary care.
Similar issues have been documented in large-scale breeding facilities for other species like birds, reptiles, and small mammals. A 2015 investigation by the Humane Society of the United States found that many major pet store chains were sourcing animals from breeding mills with documented animal welfare violations.
The impact of these practices on animal health and behavior can be severe. Animals from commercial breeding facilities often suffer from genetic disorders, behavioral issues, and chronic health problems due to inbreeding, poor nutrition, and lack of socialization. Many of these animals end up being surrendered to shelters or euthanized when their owners are unable to cope with their special needs.
Government Regulations and Oversight: Challenges and Limitations
The pet trade industry is regulated by a patchwork of federal, state, and local laws, but enforcement can be challenging and inconsistent.
At the federal level, the Animal Welfare Act (AWA) sets standards for the humane treatment of animals in commercial breeding facilities, but these standards are often criticized as being too lax and poorly enforced. A 2010 audit by the USDA‘s Office of Inspector General found that the agency was not adequately enforcing the AWA and was failing to identify and address animal welfare violations in a timely manner.
At the state and local level, regulations vary widely, with some states having more stringent breeding and pet store laws than others. However, even in states with strong regulations, enforcement can be limited by a lack of resources and personnel.
Animal welfare organizations have been working to strengthen regulations and improve industry practices through a variety of means, including:
- Advocating for stronger federal and state laws to protect animals in commercial breeding facilities and pet stores
- Conducting undercover investigations to expose animal welfare violations and raise public awareness
- Partnering with pet retailers to promote more humane and responsible sourcing practices
- Educating consumers about the importance of adoption and supporting reputable breeders and rescue organizations
What You Can Do: Making Informed and Ethical Choices
As a consumer, you have the power to influence the pet trade industry and promote more humane and responsible animal sourcing practices. Here are some steps you can take:
-
Adopt, don‘t shop. Whenever possible, consider adopting a pet from a reputable animal shelter or rescue organization instead of purchasing from a pet store or breeder. Not only will you be giving a home to an animal in need, but you‘ll also be supporting more ethical and humane practices.
-
Do your research. If you do decide to purchase a pet, take the time to research the breeder or store thoroughly. Look for red flags like a lack of transparency about their sourcing practices, a history of animal welfare violations, or an unwillingness to let you visit their facilities in person.
-
Ask questions. Don‘t be afraid to ask detailed questions about where the animal came from, how they were raised, and what kind of socialization and veterinary care they received. A reputable breeder or store should be able to provide clear and detailed answers to these questions.
-
Look for certifications and partnerships. Some breeders and pet stores partner with animal welfare organizations or participate in certification programs that prioritize humane and responsible practices. Look for these certifications and partnerships as a sign of a more ethical and trustworthy source.
-
Support animal welfare organizations. Consider donating to or volunteering with organizations that are working to improve animal welfare in the pet trade industry, such as the ASPCA, the Humane Society of the United States, or local rescue groups in your area.
-
Spread the word. Share what you‘ve learned about animal sourcing practices with friends and family who may be considering getting a pet. Encourage them to adopt from shelters or support reputable breeders and stores that prioritize animal welfare.
Conclusion
The question of where PetSmart and other pet retailers get their animals is a complex and often controversial one, with no easy answers. While PetSmart claims to prioritize humane and responsible sourcing practices, the reality is that many of their animals still come from large-scale commercial breeding facilities with a history of animal welfare concerns.
As consumers, it‘s up to us to educate ourselves about these issues and make informed and ethical choices when it comes to pet adoption and ownership. By supporting reputable shelters, rescues, and breeders, and advocating for stronger animal welfare regulations and practices, we can help create a more humane and responsible pet trade industry for all.
